Update: Wineries using Facebook!

Posted by Richard Beaudin on Jul 16, 2009 in Social Media | 0 comments

Preface:

Earlier this month I posted a blog entitled: Wineries using Facebook? You bet!

This was the result of research done on June 23rd and June 24th, 2009  regarding the over 500 wineries that have a presence on Facebook.  The data collected reflected observations and information readily available on the winery fan pages of  the top 50 winery pages.

The new survey below  provides some additional insights from the wineries themselves.

The survey request was sent  to each of the identified wineries shortly before the July 4th Holiday and was kept deliberately brief to encourage participation.

Although it would be optimal to have heard from all 50, I am very happy with the 28% response rate I received, particulary since I have no personal connection with these wineries, and so it was very gracious of them to take the time to respond to the survey.

So first let me say: THANK YOU! to all the wineries that responded. (One reason I love the wine business is because of the passion and sense of sharing I see from so many in this industry! )

Survey Results:

Note: In several instances percentages do not add up to 100 since multiple responses were possible.

When did you build your winery page on Facebook?

The two highest percentage categories (35.7%) either built their Facebook winery fan page less than 1 year ago or less than six months ago. Another 21.4% more than a year ago, and finally, 7.1% less than 3 months ago.

This is a very interesting piece of data in that the vast majority (+70%) of the respondents of the top 50 winery fan pages were built less than one year ago, suggesting relatively good acceleration in terms of building a fan base.

What activities were used by the winery to help publicize the new Facebook page?

The top activity (71.4%) was through traditional email or newsletter. The next closest activities tying at 57.1% were the placement of a widget or similar on the winery website and messages sent to Facebook fans by winery employees who  have their own account on Facebook. Other activities included PPC on another website (7.1%), PPC on Facebook (7.1%), other (28.6%), and finally, no additional activity (7.1%).

How is the Facebook page supported?

The top answer (57.1%) indicated that a single person manages the page, but multiple people participate.Insome cases, these might include shipping department personnel if a shipping question is asked, or a marketing person if there was a question regarding an event or offer.  28.6% assigned a single person with 14.2% having assigned multiple people. None of the respondents supported the page ad hoc.

Which applications on the page seem to be of most interest to your fans?

In the initial research I indicated the various applications implemented on winery Facebook pages (photos, videos, favorites, links, contests, etc.).  However, additional insight is needed in order to better understand the effectiveness of these applications.

The top two activities scored the same at 64.3%. These included events and discussions of new offerings.

The other activities of most interest included photos at 57.1%, videos at 35.7%, favorites at 14.3%, and then lastly all at 7.7% – discussions on awards, discussions on methods or processes, and discussions on “green”  (wind/solar/water reclamation).

I do believe that a more thorough vetting needs to be done regarding applications and activities.

Perhaps another survey in the future?

Does your winery participate in or use other social media or networking sites?

92.9% of the respondents indicated that they do participate in or on other social media or networking sites. The remaining respondent indicated it would soon setup a presence on Twitter.

Of the 92.9% that do participate elsewhere, 84.6% do so on Twitter, 38.5% have a separate blog, 30.8% participate on Wine2.0, 23.1% on LinkedIn, and 23.1% on the Open Wine Consortium. 7.7% indicated participation elsewhere (MySpace, Flickr).

What benefits have you achieved from investing in a fan page on Facebook?

  Finally, the proverbial question that is often asked regarding whether it is worth the effort for a winery to invest in social media. The top answer at 71.4% was gaining a better understanding of and alignment with customers. Following fairly close behind at 64.3% was an increased interest from customers or prospective customers. The remaining responses were increased stories or acticles on the net (28.6%),  increased interest from retailers, distributors or importers (14.3%), incremental members in wine club or similar (14.3%), incremental sales (14.3%), identification of new business partners (7.1%), and finally, no benefit has been realized to date (7.1%).

Summary:

So …. what are some conclusions I may suggest as a result of the survey (in addition to those from the initial research)?

1. Social media investment can build results fairly quickly. Case in point, three quarters of the top 50 respondents have built the most fans after having setup the dialogue with their customers (i.e., built their Facebook fan page) less than one year ago. You noticed, I did not suggest a quick direct payback such as incremental sales. Social media does not by any means guarantee immediate or even short term increased sales revenue. However, increased connection and dialogue with customers is significant and beneficial.
2. In order to grow fans on the Facebook page, wineries have resorted to a mix of more traditional (email/newsletter) activities and relatively new social media (widgets on website) actions.
3. None of the respondents have left the building and maintenance of the page to chance. All have one or multiple people assigned, and most have assigned the job to one person to manage.
4. All use one or more applications to help engage their fans. In some cases the simplest and most obvious work the best (photos, events, discussions of new releases).
5. Over 90% have invested beyond Facebook (with over 80% also investing in Twitter)

Finally, all of the respondents have indicated that they feel the investment has a value, although a few have not been able to directly tie the benefit to the investment.

Now for some questions:

• Could a winery build a page and accelerate even faster using more non-traditional means? For instance, using more PPC on Facebook itself to attract new fans.
• Would discussions on “green”, biodynamics, or similar draw more interest if the winery is able to identify and seek out potential fans who have strong interests in these topics?
• Can a winery gain higher participation and integration with its actual location, website, and social media presence by focusing on more integration between the three? As an example, prominantly display its fan page at the tasting room on a system and encourage visitors to input their comments and impressions from the tasting / tasting room experience (to the fan page on Facebook), then posting scrolling updates to comments on the website?
• Have all of these wineries focused as highly as they could on setting social media goals and then measuring and adjusting in order to gain a better understanding of the costs and benefits of the activity? Have they fully leveraged the excitement and enthusiasm of their customers whenever possible through testamonials or similar?

There are many additional questions to be asked..and answered. I am hoping that over time and following  interaction and dialogue with wineries that have and will invest in social media, that I will be able to report more details in the future.

Lastly, again…

My sincere thanks to all the wineries that participated in the survey and congratulations to all that made the top 50!